The Ultimate Guide to Finding Your Perfect Shoe Size

Discover expert tips for finding your perfect shoe size and avoid the frustration of ill-fitting footwear with our comprehensive guide.
Person shopping for shoes in a retail store
Written by
Jason
Published on
June 25, 2024

Table of Content

Monthly newsletter
Sign up for our newsletter and get monthly seller tips & tricks.
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.

Why Proper Shoe Sizing Matters

Finding the right shoe size is more than just comfort—it's about foot health, performance, and getting the most value from your purchase. Studies show that nearly 80% of people wear the wrong shoe size, leading to discomfort, blisters, and even long-term foot problems.

How to Measure Your Feet Correctly

What You'll Need

  • A ruler or measuring tape
  • A piece of paper larger than your foot
  • A pen or pencil
  • A wall or flat surface

Step-by-Step Measurement Guide

1. Prepare Your Measurement Space

Place the paper on a hard floor against a wall. Make sure you're standing up—your foot size can change when bearing weight.

2. Trace Your Foot

Stand on the paper with your heel against the wall. Have someone trace around your foot, keeping the pencil perpendicular to the paper.

3. Measure Length and Width

  • Length: Measure from the heel to the longest toe
  • Width: Measure the widest part of your foot

4. Measure Both Feet

Most people have slightly different sized feet. Always go with the measurements of your larger foot.

Understanding Size Charts

Shoe sizes vary significantly between brands and countries. Here's what you need to know:

US vs. International Sizing

  • US Women's 8 = UK 5.5 = EU 38.5 = 24.1 cm
  • US Men's 10 = UK 9 = EU 43 = 27.9 cm

Brand-Specific Variations

Different brands often have unique fits:

  • Nike: Tends to run narrow; consider going up half a size
  • Adidas: Generally true to size but varies by model
  • New Balance: Available in width options (Narrow, Standard, Wide, Extra Wide)
  • Converse: Usually runs large; many people size down

Common Sizing Mistakes to Avoid

1. Shopping in the Morning

Your feet swell throughout the day. Shop for shoes in the afternoon or evening for the most accurate fit.

2. Ignoring Width

Length isn't everything! If your feet are wide or narrow, look for brands that offer width options.

3. Not Trying Both Shoes

Always try on both shoes and walk around. What feels good sitting down might not work when you're moving.

4. Assuming All Brands Fit the Same

Just because you're a size 9 in one brand doesn't mean you're a 9 in all brands. Always check sizing guides.

Pro Tips for Online Shoe Shopping

  1. Read reviews: Other customers often mention if shoes run large or small
  2. Check return policies: Make sure you can return shoes if they don't fit
  3. Order multiple sizes: Many retailers offer free returns—order 2-3 sizes and return what doesn't fit
  4. Use Size.ly: Our AI-powered sizing recommendations analyze your measurements and preferences to suggest the perfect size

When to Size Up or Down

Size Up If:

  • You plan to wear thick socks
  • You have wide feet or high arches
  • You're buying running shoes (you need wiggle room)
  • Reviews say the shoe runs small

Size Down If:

  • You have narrow feet
  • The shoe is a slip-on style
  • Reviews consistently say it runs large
  • You're between sizes and prefer a snug fit

Special Considerations

Athletic Shoes

Running and training shoes need about a thumb's width of space between your longest toe and the end of the shoe. This prevents toe injuries and allows for foot expansion during exercise.

Dress Shoes

Dress shoes often run narrower than athletic shoes. If you're buying leather shoes, remember they'll stretch slightly with wear.

Kids' Shoes

Children's feet grow quickly—check their shoe size every 2-3 months. Allow about a thumb's width of growing room, but not too much or they'll trip.

The Size.ly Advantage

At Size.ly, we've simplified the entire process. Our AI-powered sizing tool:

  • Analyzes your measurements and fit preferences
  • Compares against thousands of shoe models and reviews
  • Provides personalized size recommendations for any brand
  • Reduces return rates by up to 40%

Conclusion

Finding the perfect shoe size doesn't have to be complicated. By measuring your feet correctly, understanding how different brands fit, and using tools like Size.ly, you can shop with confidence—whether online or in-store.

Remember: the right size is the one that feels comfortable, supports your foot properly, and suits the activity you're doing. Don't get too hung up on the number—focus on the fit!

Ready to find your perfect size? Try Size.ly's AI-powered sizing tool for personalized recommendations across all your favorite brands.

Selling Clothing Online?

Solve the Size Issue & Create Size Charts that Reduce Returns and Keep Your Customers Happy.

A green check mark on a black background

Cut Returns by 50%

A green check mark on a black background

Boost Sales by 26%

A green check mark on a black background

Create in Seconds

A green check mark on a black background

300+ Designs

A green check mark on a black background

Automatic Conversion

A green check mark on a black background

Platform Agnostic

Discover our latest blog posts

Size, Sell, Succeed

Your comprehensive guide to online selling, buying tips, and the latest in fashion trends.
Selling Tips

How to Block a Buyer on eBay

Learn how to block a user on eBay from bidding or purchasing from you in a couple simple steps.
Sophie Clipton
December 21, 2019
5 min read
Selling Tips

A Comprehensive Guide to Selling on Mercari in 2023

Discover the ultimate guide to selling on Mercari in 202! From setting up your account to maximizing your profits, this comprehensive article has everything you need to succeed in the world of onli...
Alize Mendez
September 21, 2023
5 min read
Selling Tips

10 Alternatives to eBay

eBay is awesome, but here are some alternative worth looking into as well...
Alize Mendez
August 18, 2018
5 min read

COPYRIGHT © SIZELY 2025. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.